Take a Breath

by Theresa Spranger, Bioethics Program Alumna (MSBioethics 2012)

The country has been gripped with interest watching the case of Sarah Murnaghan.  Sarah is a 10 year old Cystic Fibrosis patient who was in desperate need of a lung transplant.  The current transplant waiting list rules state that children under the age of 12 can receive lungs from an adult donor only if those lungs are not needed for an adult or adolescent in the same geographical area.

On the surface this may sound malicious and unjust, but let’s dig deeper.  In order for a child, under the age of 12, to receive adult lungs they must be re-sized for the smaller chest cavity of the child.  Current research says that this re-sizing process can make the lungs less stable and the transplant less successful than adolescent or adult transplants.

Being a logical thinker these types of media frenzy stories drive me batty.  An uneducated public is led by a manipulative or possibly, equally uneducated media to “react” on emotion rather than truly think about the issue.  In a moment the country was abuzz about the “unfair” transplant allocation rules and how we need to change them RIGHT NOW!

I am not saying that these rules don’t need to be updated; I am certainly no authority on lung allocation or transplantation.  My knowledge in this area is limited to information that came up in my recent Google search.  We may very well need to change the process, but let’s take our time, use logic, and consult the experts.

Certainly, Sarah’s story is heart wrenching and no one wants to see a little girl’s life end.  Medical policy however, cannot be created based on preventing whichever outcome would make us the most sad.  UNOS, the United Network for Organ Sharing, has difficult, almost impossible decisions to make every day about who receives the organs they have available.  They have to make these decisions logically and free of emotion.  To be truly just, they need to give the organs to patients who will benefit from them the most, this includes considering which transplants will be the most successful.

After the nationwide outcry and a court order, Sarah’s name was given priority on the lung transplant list.  She received her transplant and her body almost immediately rejected the lungs.  Three days later Sarah received a second transplant; it is extremely rare to receive two transplants so close together.  This second surgery was approximately two weeks ago, and according to press releases from her parents Sarah is doing well.

We should certainly all be happy for Sarah and her family and pray for her continued recovery.  I have no issue at all with the Murnaghan’s fight for their daughter.  I understand what it means to have a family member with a terminal illness and the need to exhaust every resource within reach to save them.  Any avenue that brings a family peace or allows them to continue the fight is fine with me.

I am disappointed however with the reactive media and general public.  Organ allocation is a complex process and should be treated as such.  This means any proposed changes should be thoughtful, logical, and well supported with data.  Sarah’s story stirs emotions in us and we want to help her, but what about the other people on the transplant list?

Maybe there is a 15 year old honors student, or a 22 year old with aspirations for medical school, or a 25 year old mother of 2, or 40 year old father of 5.  We need to keep in mind that Sarah’s is the story we know, but not the only sad story on the lung transplant waiting list.  We trust UNOS with the decisions, because they have a commitment to making them logically, based on need and benefit rather than emotion.

[This blog entry was originally posted in a slightly edited form on Ms. Spranger’s blog on June 30, 2013. Its contents are solely the responsibility of the author alone and do not represent the views of the Bioethics Program or Union Graduate College.]


3 thoughts on “Take a Breath

  1. I’ve been so irritated all of this. The parents gaming the system, the comments saying children should have priority over adults, and the failure of the first transplant. I’m considering pulling my name from organ donation.

    • Hi Sharon,

      I understand your frustration, but encourage you to look at the situation from Sarah’s mother’s perspective. I can’t blame her for doing all she could to save her sweet daughter, and it appears, for a little while at least, that she has which is a blessing for her family. I am not angry that the parent’s pursued this road, but am disappointed at the rash reaction of the media, politicians, and populous.

      Organ donation is so important, I truly hope you don’t reconsider your decision to donate because of this case. Thank you for taking the time to read my article.

      • I’ve tried to, and while I don’t blame them the fact that they were able to “buy” their way into it, and someone who didn’t have the means and money is while others in the same situation does not sit well with me. It angers me frankly.
        The American public is so dumbed down at this point, with a severe lack of critical thinking skills it comes as no surprise they ‘won’. The media sells news and has lost its’ public obligation to report the facts, not create a sideshow. And the politicians: well they know how to play to their Anti Science, pro Creationist constituents who are destroying our public education system.
        The whole children > adults in just about every issue infuriates me. I have a friend who is near homeless and suicidal yet Social Services won’t assist her because ” she doesn’t have children”. I don’t either and this is personal to me.
        I believe in organ donation, and the odds are I will stay a donor, but this really angered me. Thank you for replying, it is an excellent article

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s